The AI music generation space is heating up. Google just launched Lyria 3 through Gemini and YouTube Dream Track, joining established players Suno and Udio. Here's how they stack up.
The Players
Suno
- Valuation: ~$2B (raising $100M in 2026)
- Users: 950M+ AI music app users (Q2 2025)
- Strengths: Longest track output, multi-stem editing, professional studio features
- Best for: Musicians and producers who want control
- Pricing: Free tier + $10-30/month pro
Udio
- Strengths: High quality outputs, strong community, rapid iteration
- Best for: Quick creation and experimentation
- Pricing: Free credits + $10/mo subscription
Google Lyria 3 (via Gemini)
- Strengths: Integrated with Google ecosystem, 30-second tracks with lyrics + cover art
- Best for: Content creators needing quick tracks for videos
- Pricing: Included in Gemini Advanced ($20/mo)
Feature Comparison
| Feature | Suno | Udio | Lyria |
|---|---|---|---|
| Max length | 4 min | 2 min | 30 sec |
| Multi-stem export | ✅ | Partial | ❌ |
| Vocals input | ✅ | ✅ | ❌ |
| Instrument input | ✅ | ❌ | ❌ |
| Cover art | Manual | Manual | Auto |
| API access | Limited | Limited | Google API |
Key Observations from Podcasts
The 30-second limitation: Google intentionally limits Lyria to short outputs. This positions it for "demo" use cases rather than full production. As one podcast noted, "no serious person will use it for music creation yet."
Training data controversy: Suno and Udio face ongoing lawsuits from record labels over training data. Google took a more conservative approach with watermarking (Synth ID) but limits capabilities.
Professional workflow: The pros use Suno for "ideation" - quickly sketching ideas - then export stems for full production in traditional DAWs.
Which Should You Use?
For quick video soundtracks: Lyria (free with Gemini)
For independent music creation: Suno (best features)
For experimentation and speed: Udio (fastest iteration)
The Bigger Picture
AI music generation is following the same trajectory as image generation:
- Consumer tools (quick, limited)
- Professional tools (expensive, powerful)
- Integration into creative workflows
We're currently in phase 1-2 transition. The winners will be tools that integrate best into existing production workflows.
Want more AI tool comparisons? tldl summarizes podcasts from founders and operators building these tools.
Related Content
- Suno vs Udio: Complete Comparison — Deep dive into the two leading platforms
- Suno V5 Studio Guide — Complete guide to Suno's latest features
- Best AI Music Generators — Curated directory of AI music tools